TL;DR
When eDiscovery disputes reach a judge, claims about proportionality, cost, or undue burden are more persuasive when supported by concrete evidence. A conversation I had with a federal judge reinforced an important lesson: show your work. Documenting data sources, custodians, search methodologies, volumes, costs, and good faith efforts to resolve disagreements can help legal teams present clearer, more defensible discovery arguments.
Several years ago, I was introduced to a friend of a friend at dinner. After the usual small talk, the conversation turned to, “What do you do for a living?” I dread this question. Even after 17 years in eDiscovery at the time, some of my closest family and friends still did not fully understand my career.
For that reason, I asked first. I quickly learned that I was speaking with a federal judge before whom I had never appeared or worked.
I was not going to let that opportunity pass without asking questions. Luckily, the judge was patient and forthcoming. We discussed how courts were adapting to eDiscovery, how judges learned from one another, and what made technical discovery arguments useful from the bench.
One point has stayed with me: when parties ask a court to evaluate proportionality, cost, burden, or a motion to compel discovery, conclusions alone do not give a judge much to work with. The parties should be prepared to show their work.
Why eDiscovery Disputes Escalate
Discovery disputes arise when parties disagree about what information should be preserved, searched, reviewed, or produced. In electronically stored information (ESI) discovery, those disagreements can involve email, text messages, collaboration platforms, databases, files, mobile devices, or other digital sources.
The disagreement may start with scope. One side sees requested information as important, while the other considers the request duplicative, difficult to access, disproportionately expensive, or unlikely to produce useful information.
Questions about the duty to preserve electronically stored information, ESI protocols, custodians, data sources, search methodologies, or production requirements can significantly affect the size and cost of a discovery project.
A productive meet-and-confer process can narrow these differences. When parties exchange meaningful information about available ESI, technical limitations, and potential costs, they are better positioned to resolve disagreements based on facts rather than assumptions.
Judges Know More About eDiscovery Than They Used To
One thing the judge and I discussed was increasing communication among judges about eDiscovery. That cooperation was helping close the education gap between attorneys, their experts, and the court.
Earlier in the development of eDiscovery, I encountered attitudes suggesting some judges wished electronic discovery issues would disappear or thought technology-heavy matters belonged with younger judges. That is historical context, not a useful description of the current judiciary.
Judicial resources have become substantially more developed. The Sedona Conference Cooperation Proclamation: Resources for the Judiciary, Fourth Edition, published in August 2025, provides guidance for managing discovery disputes, including those involving ESI. It emphasizes proportionality, cooperation, and active judicial case management.
These resources reflect the growing importance of understanding technology within the discovery process.
As judicial familiarity develops, technical terminology alone becomes less useful. A court considering an eDiscovery dispute may ask practical questions about what data exists, how it was evaluated, which methodologies were used, and why a particular request creates the claimed burden.
Attorneys and eDiscovery professionals should be prepared to answer those questions with clear, supporting information.
How Rule 26 Proportionality Frames the Dispute
For discovery disputes in federal court, Rule 26 provides an important framework.
Under Federal Rule of Civil Procedure 26(b)(1), parties generally may obtain discovery of nonprivileged information that is relevant to a party’s claim or defense and proportional to the needs of the case.
The rule identifies several proportionality factors:
- The importance of the issues at stake in the action.
- The amount in controversy.
- The parties’ relative access to relevant information.
- The parties’ resources.
- The importance of the discovery in resolving the issues.
- Whether the burden or expense of the proposed discovery outweighs its likely benefit.
These factors make proportionality in discovery dependent on the circumstances of the case. Simply stating that a request is too broad, expensive, or burdensome does not establish the facts supporting that position.
Rule 26(b)(2)(B) also addresses ESI that a party identifies as not reasonably accessible because of undue burden or cost.
When that designation is challenged through a motion to compel or protective order, the responding party must demonstrate why the information is not reasonably accessible. Even when that showing is made, a court may still order discovery if the requesting party establishes good cause, subject to the applicable limitations. The court may also impose conditions on discovery.
These distinctions matter because a burden objection does not automatically eliminate a discovery obligation.
From an eDiscovery perspective, the practical lesson is straightforward: legal arguments about scope, accessibility, cost, and proportionality are easier to evaluate when supported by reliable technical information.
What Showing Your Work Looks Like
This was my favorite takeaway from the conversation with the judge, and it remains one of the most useful eDiscovery best practices I can share.
If a party argues that collecting, reviewing, and producing ESI would be disproportionately expensive, the estimate should have a documented foundation. If a party files a motion to compel discovery, the scope of the requested information and the remaining disagreement should be understandable.
Showing your work may include:
- Custodians and data sources: Identifying relevant individuals, systems, repositories, and potentially responsive information.
- Data volumes: Documenting estimated collection sizes, processing volumes, and review populations.
- Search methodologies: Recording search terms, date restrictions, hit counts, and filtering approaches.
- Data reduction techniques: Explaining how deduplication, file type filtering, and other methods affect the amount of information requiring review.
- Cost and time estimates: Identifying assumptions behind projected collection, processing, hosting, review, and production costs.
- Supporting technical documentation: Providing declarations, expert affidavits, or other appropriate evidence explaining how conclusions were reached.
During my conversation with the judge, we discussed the frustration caused by cost and burden arguments that lacked meaningful supporting detail.
Even affidavits from IT professionals and eDiscovery experts may present specific cost estimates without adequately explaining the underlying methodologies. For example, a projection based on data that has already been reduced through deduplication, date restrictions, or keyword filtering may tell a different story than an estimate based on the original collection volume.
Those differences can materially affect a court’s understanding of the work involved.
Custodian interviews can also help eDiscovery professionals identify where potentially relevant information resides, understand overlapping data sources, and assess collection requirements.
Platforms such as Relativity can support the analysis of search results, data volumes, document populations, and review progress. That information can help legal teams develop more informed estimates and evaluate alternative discovery approaches.
Technology-assisted review and AI-supported workflows may also influence assumptions about review time, cost, and burden. However, their effectiveness depends on the technology, implementation, validation, quality control, and characteristics of the data involved.
The objective is not to present the most favorable number. It is to provide an understandable explanation of how the estimate was developed.
When legal teams can explain their assumptions and methodologies, they are better equipped to support informed discovery decisions.
Good Faith Cooperation Can Keep Disputes Focused
Resolving discovery disputes does not always require court intervention.
The Sedona Conference’s guidance emphasizes cooperation throughout discovery, including identifying ESI sources, preservation, collection, processing, review, production, and dispute resolution.
A documented record of good faith discussions can help clarify what the parties considered, where they reached agreement, and which issues remain unresolved.
That information may also support a more focused resolution process if judicial involvement becomes necessary.
Effective cooperation begins before a dispute escalates. Legal teams benefit from understanding their data environments, anticipated discovery requirements, and the practical implications of proposed collection and review approaches.
An established ESI protocol can help define expectations and reduce disagreements over preservation, searching, production formats, and related technical issues.
Complete Legal’s resource, Stay Ahead of the Curve with Essential ESI Protocols and Discovery Plans, explains how structured protocols can help legal teams manage discovery obligations and reduce unnecessary disputes.
Similarly, How to Prepare Data for eDiscovery Before Sending It to Your Vendor discusses identifying custodians, understanding data sources, and developing defensible collection workflows.
Careful planning and reasonable preservation efforts also help reduce the separate risks associated with the failure to preserve electronically stored information.
The objective is not to manufacture a record for a fight. It is to develop enough shared information that the actual problem becomes clear before further escalation.
Bring Better Information to eDiscovery Decisions
Technology has changed considerably since my conversation with that federal judge, but the most valuable lesson has not.
Courts have more resources for understanding eDiscovery, and unsupported claims about cost, burden, and technical difficulty provide less useful information than documented facts.
Legal teams that understand their data, methodologies, and assumptions are better positioned to communicate clearly when discovery disagreements arise.
That preparation may involve more than simply calculating document volumes or generating cost estimates. Complex disputes can require technical analysis, experienced consulting, and supporting documentation that translates discovery workflows into information attorneys can use.
Complete Legal helps litigation teams assess ESI, develop defensible discovery strategies, support collection and processing, and evaluate review workflows in Relativity.
Through its eDiscovery consulting services, Complete Legal also supports ESI protocol development and negotiation, technical assessments, expert reports, affidavits, and expert testimony when appropriate.
These capabilities help attorneys understand the practical implications of discovery requests and make informed decisions about scope, cost, and proportionality.
When discovery questions become complicated, having experienced professionals who can explain the technology and support their conclusions can make a meaningful difference.
Contact Us: to discuss your eDiscovery challenges and explore how our team can help.
📧 info@completelegal.us | 📞 888-885-9909
Key Takeaways
- Support discovery arguments with facts. Claims about scope, cost, proportionality, and undue burden are more useful when supported by documented technical information.
- Understand Rule 26 requirements. Federal discovery generally requires relevance and proportionality, while ESI accessibility disputes may involve additional considerations, including good cause.
- Document methodologies and assumptions. Custodians, data sources, search terms, hit counts, filtering methods, estimated volumes, and costs help explain how conclusions were reached.
- Prioritize good faith cooperation. Productive meet-and-confer discussions and clear ESI protocols can narrow disagreements before judicial intervention becomes necessary.
- Use experienced eDiscovery support. Technical assessments, defensible workflows, expert reports, and affidavits can help legal teams present reliable information and make informed discovery decisions.